Thursday, 21 April 2016

Evaluation Question No.3

What have you learned from your audience feedback?



The main purpose of our first audience questionnaire was to determine who our audience were and whether they liked the film or not. Knowing this would help us develop our storyline and allow us to improve any parts of the narrative which were lacking in entertainment value.

In order to gather the opinions of our audience in regards to our initial storyline, we created an online questionnaire on Surveymonkey.com which allowed us to figure out which parts of our storyline were effective and which parts could be improved upon. Before our audience answered our questionnaire we allowed them to read a short synopsis which detailed what would occur. The first couple of questions focused upon the audience themselves as we determined who they were. The rest of the questions focused upon the level of entertainment the audience experienced and how they believed it could be improve upon. The responses were important as they helped us determine which parts of our film weren't as good as others, and therefore we could edit the storyline of these scenes in order to improve the overall quality of our film. From our 8 participants such responses included:
We utilised the constructive criticisim given to us by our audience such as "Having a greater number of characters", "Making the time travel more involved" and "Includ[ing] more action." In regards to having more characters this would be extremely difficult as we only had 4 characters within our filming group and therefore it would be difficult to include any more people as the maximum we could have acting, was 3 people and one person filming on the camera. However in the hospital scene, which we filmed in the medical section of Barnsley College we asked some people to be background actors in order to make the hospital appear more busy and therefore more reliable. 


In regards to making the time travel more involved, we attempted to make the transition of time more obvious to the audience as some respondents didn't fully comprehend or were partially confused by the time travel aspect. Therefore when editing the hospital scene we included a rewinding sound effect when Joey is messing with the watch to denote time going back. Then when Joey and Hanna return to the site of the crash and Joey throws the watch away we added a light effect on the discarded watch, which showed the sunny setting changing to a more cloudy setting which was apparent on the day of the crash. Therefore by doing this the audience would be able to figure out that time had returned. 

Finally in regards to including more action within our film, we were able to make the car crash have a greater impact on our audience. Through the use of editing through Adobe Premiere Pro we were able to speed up the crash as well as including screeching sound effects as well as crashing noises and a fade to black which would make the scene appear fast and shocking to our audience. The aftermath of the crash was also important as we edited the POV shot of Joey exiting the car (evidently injured) through the implementation of ringing noises and blurred vision. This editing denoted the obvious debilitation of Joey and implied to the audience that the car crash had been extremely serious and life threatening. 



Our film features a what could be confusing storyline and therefore we aimed to provide the audience with a clear representation of our storyline. We needed to convey the ability of watch to turn back time which was the main factor within our film. During planning for our storyline we needed to develop a scene which would convey the magical powers of the watch to our audience. We decided the powers of the watch would be hinted initially by the homeless man who would declare to Joey that the watch would change his life, then while driving in the car Joey would say, “there's something about this watch” however if the audience hadn't understood the powers of the watch by this moment we decided we needed a more obvious scene. This scene we decided would be when Aidan is in a critical condition and his sister Hanna is visiting and bringing coffee for a recovering Joey. However she drops the coffee and proceeds to leave the room to get something to clean it up with. Hanna returns two more times with the same tray of coffee and drops it again and again. During these accidents Joey is shown tweaking the watch and to convey the powers of the watch through editing we included a rewinding noise of the dialogue between Joey and Hanna. From these implementations our audience would be able to figure out the powers of watch which is the main factor within our film. 

However if our audience hadn't realised the abilities of the watch by this point, we decided we would implement another editing process in order to convey the intended message. This message came in the form of the discarding of the watch scene. After Joey and Hanna have returned to the site of the crash to place flowers, Joey attempts to reverse time similarly to the hospital scene, however he is unable to do so. He therefore throws the watch away in a burst of anger. When the watch is shown through the close up however, the implication is that the watch has turned back time. In order to convey this message to the audience we used a lighting effect which altered the sunny shot to a more cloudy and gradually darker shot. Through this the audience should have been able to realise that the watch had the ability to turn back time, and therefore when the Homeless Man reappears as well as Aidan and the past tense Joey in the car the audience members shouldn't be experiencing confusion. 





Once we had finished filming and editing we released the first draft of our film on youtube for our audience to view. Once the audience had finished watch the film they answered our questionnaire on paper which would give us some ideas on how to improve our editing process. The types of questions we used would allow us to determine any misinterpretations our audience had about the film, as well as which were their favourite and least favourite scenes. Knowing this would allow us to further edit these scene in order to achieve a balanced film where all the scenes appeared professional and interesting.


























We questioned 18 people in total which would give us a good estimate on how good our film was and let us know whether our audience thought it was a professional and entertaining film. The responses we received were extremely helpful and once we had questioned all 18 individuals we grouped the responses for each question in tables and charts which would help ourselves visualise the results. Below are a few examples of the answers that we received. 


From the responses we received from question number eight is it clear that the favourite scenes for our audience were the crash scene and the final scene which contain the highest amount of action and benefit the narrative the most. Despite knowing this, the most important information comes from the hospital scene, the first scene and the return to the crash scene. Knowing these scenes were the least interesting meant we were able to focus on editing these sections to create a more well rounded film. For example in the hospital scene we were able to increase the volume of the speakers as we discovered the sound was a little hard to hear, as well as altering the sound of the heartbeat in the background, and finally the last scene which showed Aidan in a critical condition. 


 The narrative of our film may appear confusing at first, however with the use of editing and professional cinematography we believe we have made the storyline as clear to the audience as possible without reducing the level of entertainment. However from the results of question three we discovered there was still a minority who found parts of our film confusing. In regards to the response "hospital scene is a little confusing..." we implemented the sound of the watch reversing time in conjunction with the extreme close up on the watch. However this response was given prior to the editing of the rewind noise, and we therefore believe there is little else we could have done to imply to our audience that the watch could reverse time. In regards to the return to the crash scene and the reversal of time not being explicit we made the lighting effect on the watch when time is reversed more noticeable as the initial shot shows a sunny day, whereas by the end of the shot the setting has become darker and cloudier. 




























When we began planning for our film we aimed to create a professional looking movie which would be entertaining for our audience. However from question four we discovered that a minority found parts of our film amateur. After viewing the responses we found there were minor details which made the film look unprofessional and we began to correct these through editing on Premiere Pro. We implemented a credit sequence following the final scene which included all of the names of the actors and actresses as well as some non diegetic music. In the final scene where the homeless man returns we altered the editing of the shot where he is pushed out of the trajectory of the car by Joey, as the first draft showed the homeless man standing then by the next shot he had mysteriously collapsed on the floor, with the shot therefore lacking continuity. Finally in the hospital scene we increased the sound of the characters and altered minor parts of the editing in order to balance this with the otherwise high quality scenes. 

The ending of our film can be described as being ambiguous as it isn't clear whether Joey or Aidan have realised what they have just seen, or what will happen to the Homeless Man. For question number seven of our evaluation we discovered that 100% of the people we asked thought there could be a sequel to our film. In terms of the cultural interpretation of our film, our audience may view our characters in various ways. A stereotypical teenager for example will sympathise with Aidan and Joey after they crash, as they are archetypal teenage boys which is highlighted in their dress sense, the way they speak and the way they act. However somebody who has had experience with being homeless may sympathise with the Homeless Man, more than the two boys, as the homeless man clearly uses alcohol in order to forget his troubles, and his level of desperation is shown through the fact he tries to sell a branded watch for £5. Therefore when the Homeless Man is run over an audience member who has experienced living on the streets may be more concerned for the Homeless man, instead of Joey and Aidan.

No comments:

Post a Comment